How to Validate Your Membership Idea Before You Build It

You've got an idea for a membership. Maybe you've already sketched out what goes in it, what you'll deliver, what people get for staying. Before you build a single piece of it, there's one question worth answering: is what you're planning actually what people want?

Most people skip this. They build first, launch, and find out afterward that the thing they spent three months creating wasn't the thing anyone was asking for. Or worse, it was close enough that people joined and then left after two months because it didn't deliver what they thought it would.

Validation isn't a survey with a few yes-or-no questions. It's conversations with real people who match who you're building for, asking questions specific enough that the answers tell you something useful. "Would you join a membership about SEO?" gets you a polite yes. "What's the thing you keep getting stuck on with SEO?" gets you the actual problem, in their words, which is what your membership needs to solve.

The Membership Plan Validator gives you both halves of that work.

Five ready-to-use questions you can drop into a conversation, a DM, or a survey. They're written to surface what people are actually stuck on, what they've already tried, and what "worth it" looks like to them.

Then five starters you customize using your own membership promise and learning goals. These test your specific plan rather than a generic idea. You'll find out whether what you're planning to deliver matches what people say they need, and where the gaps are.

Plus a short guide on what to do with the answers. You're looking for patterns, not unanimous agreement, and there's a difference between an outlier and a signal.

Five to ten conversations will tell you more than months of building.

You'll also get Cut the Crap, a biweekly newsletter on course and membership design that skips the hype and gets to the point. Unsubscribe anytime.